Kim Miller argues that there have
been too many unnecessary horse deaths.
Wild horse supporters blame the Bureau of Land Management for these
deaths due to not handling the horses properly.
She claims that the lack of public awareness is one of the reasons not
many people have stood up against the round ups. Miller develops this claim by first
investigating wild horse advocate groups, which include celebrities like Viggo
Mortensen and Sheryl Crow. The groups
feel that the horses are being treated unfairly and inhumanely. Miller informs us according to the Bureau of
Land Management, there are an estimated 37,000 wild horses roaming on public
land. They feel that this number is
10,000 horses over the acceptable herd size.
Lastly, the author hopes that with additional public awareness, there
will be more postponements of scheduled round ups. Kim Miller’s purpose is to bring this issue
to the public in order to save the last part of America’s wild west. This work
is significant because it creates a public awareness of what the Bureau of Land
Management is doing to these horses and that if we do not speak up against it,
they will continue to reduce the wild population until they are extinct.
Friday, October 5, 2012
Wild Horses Get People's Attention
The Mustang Mystique
Abigail Tucker argues that the round
up of wild horses and mustangs is distasteful in the extreme. She describes that when they round up the
wild horses and mustangs, they use helicopters to get the horses running. Then they release a “Judas horse” which is a
tamed horse who runs in front of the herd.
The horse leads the wild horses into a corral and they close the
gates. Tucker develops this claim by
first interviewing Melissa Farlow, a wild horse photographer, about her
experiences around the wild horses. She
also spoke to Karen Sussman, president of the International Society for the
Protection of Mustangs and Burros, who believes that the wild horses should be
treated like wildlife instead of livestock.
Additional information was gained from Tom Gorey, spokesperson for the
Bureau of Land Management, who tries to justify reducing herd sizes. Tucker
lists statistics of how many horses are left out in the wild and how many are
in long term and short term holding facilities.
Lastly, the author describes the difficulty of adopting the wild horses
into good homes. The adoption costs are
low, but the cost to keep and maintain the horses is expensive. Abigail Tucker’s purpose is to inform us of
the wild horses and mustangs in order to help save them from becoming extinct. This work is significant because it describes
how many horses are still in the wild and what happens to the horses during and
after the round up.
Change of Scenery for America's Wild Horses
Dee McVicker informs us that U.S.
Interior Secretary Ken Salazar plans to build seven new wild horse preserves
which would be managed by the Bureau of Land Management. Salazar describes that the preserves will be
“an excellent opportunity to showcase these historic animals while boasting
ecotourism for rural communities.” She
claims that wild horse advocates challenge his idea that the western range land
will not be able to support the existing herds.
Ginger Kathrens feels that there are 33,000 horses at the most, compared
to five to eight million head of cattle.
McVicker develops this information by first investigating Ken Salazar
and finding out his proposals and ideas.
She also researched Ginger Kathrens and found her views. McVicker discovered Salazar had a least one
supporter. Madeleine Pickens, a
prominent wild horse activist, announced plans to establish a wild horse
sanctuary for 30,000 horses. Lastly, the
author creates awareness that the Bureau of Land Management plans to remove
12,000 wild horses from the rangeland this year. Dee McVicker’s purpose is to explore the
options available for the unadoptable wild horses in order to urge readers to
become more involved in the outcome of the wild horses future. This work is significant because it
illustrates the other options available for the wild horses besides crammed
corrals or euthanization.
McVicker, Dee. "Change Of
Scenery For America's Wild Horses?." Equus 388 (2010): 60-61. SPORTDiscus
with Full Text. Web. 10 Sept. 2012.\
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)